1

How close is the language of Os Lusíadas to the modern Portuguese? More specifically, would this text be suitable for learning Portuguese, as, e.g., one uses some epic texts for learning Latin or Greek (e.g., reading through Aeneid or Iliad/Odyssey respectively.)

I have read that the difference between modern Portuguese and the Camões texts is like between modern English and Shakespeare. In this respect, although Shakespeare sounds a bit off, occasionally uses some odd words, and certainly lacks modern terms, it is still readable and pretty much modern in terms of syntax and basic vocabulary.

As an extension of the question: I would be also interested in references to Os Lusíadas with interlinear/byline/parallel English or French text.

1

1 Answer 1

2

The Portuguese language at that time was, naturally, a bit different from all modern varieties:

  • in terms of (i) vowel sounds (being more open), (ii) stress and prosody (being stress-timed), as well as (iii) a major tendency of putting the "unstressed pronouns" before the verb (in a way that looks like other modern Romance languages, using it after the verb only in some cases) (sentences like "me ajuda" (help me) are common), (iv) the construction of progressive sentences with the gerund (estou andando (I am walking)), it resembles Brazilian dialects.

  • in terms of (v) consonants, (vi) pronouns and their respective conjugations, it resembles European dialcts, specially those from the north.

And it makes sense, both variaties of the language are daughters of the same previous version, however, all dialects from these varieties had lots of inovations, it is natural. English had many changes from Shakespeare's time to modern days, such as the Great Vowel Shift, the general lost of thou, thee, thy, thine and the second person singular conjugation etc. It is also worth noticing that Camões and Shakespear lived at the same time and used a very poetic and refined vocabulary and stuff.

So, knowing that, I add that no, it is not a good text when you start learning. I guess you could study it as one studies The Eneid for instance, but you will have to know some Latin before to do that, or Antient Greek for the Odyssey etc.

Here you have the first edition of "The Lusiad", the translation of "Os Lusíadas" in English.

Versions in Portuguese are really easy to find online and in physical copies!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.