9

To be honest, primary school was long ago and I can't remember if I was taught any rule. I know when to use "s" or "z" from everyday usage, I presume.

  • we use an "s" in such verbs as atrasar, alisar, analisar, avisar, pesquisar, paralisar, arrasar, extravasar, frisar, etc.

  • and a "z" is used in agonizar, amenizar, batizar, concretizar, simpatizar, utilizar, realizar, civilizar, etc.

For those who are learning Portuguese as a foreign language, this must be a hard nut to crack. Is there any rule to make things easier for the student?

10

Verbs that end in -sar are derived from nouns whose last syllable has already an "s", if that syllable is preserved in the transition to the verbal variation. Otherwise, the -zar form will be used.

The examples you mention are quite illustrative:

atrasar/atraso, alisar/(a)liso, analisar/análise, avisar/aviso, pesquisar/pesquisa, paralisar/parálise(paralisia), arrasar/(ar)raso, extravasar/(extra)vaso, frisar/friso.

agonizar/agonia, amenizar/ameno, batizar/batismo, concretizar/concreto, simpatizar/simpatia, utilizar/útil, realizar/real, civilizar/civil.

  • Very interesting. If you could provide links, your answer would be a great contribution to our site. – Centaurus Aug 23 '15 at 23:39
  • 1
    All the sources I found didn't say anything about the origin of this rule. It may come from usage, from norm, or both. In any case, the logic behind it probably has to do with the history of the phoneme [z] in Portuguese. As I understand it, most words where "s" is used with a [z] sound were originally pronounced with an [s] sound, but kept being written as before, causing the confusion. – André Souza Lemos Aug 24 '15 at 1:03
  • Interestingly, analizar is an obsolete spelling of analisar. – tchrist Aug 26 '15 at 0:21
  • He's right. But some words like catequizar is from "catechizare" and not catequese. So it's not as simple like always. – Carlos Henrique Jan 22 '18 at 2:35
  • Sorry, but is there a pronunciation difference between z and s in these examples? They are all [z]. So how can that be?? The sounds for the verbs are all the same regardless of sar or zar....... – Lambie Jan 22 '18 at 18:12

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.